Antananarivo is looking for resource deals with Asian
financiers to raise cash for an election campaign for interim leader Andry
Rajoelina
The transitional regime led by Andry Rajoelina is threatening to cancel oil
exploration licences held by Western investors and hand them to the Hong
Kong-based China International Fund. Rajoelina, who seized power with army
support in March 2009, needs money to fight presidential elections due in
mid-year, which are shaping up to be a bitter confrontation with desposed
President Marc Ravalomanana and several other candidates.
Refusing to recognise Rajoelina’s legitimacy after the putsch that brought him
to power, the Southern African Development Community, the African Union and the
European Union are demanding strict conditions for a return to constitional rule
in Madgascar. However, Rajoelina has been able to build up a strong local
political support base and win finance on natural resource deals from Indian,
Chinese and Pakistani companies (see box).The immediate targets for the
Rajoelina regime are the four licences held by London-listed Madagascar Oil,
whose operations at the Tsimororo oil field are now subject to a state audit. If
the audits find that Madagascar Oil has breached local regulations, the state
will press its claims to buy back the licences.
State officials in Antananarivo are also planning to audit the operations of
Ireland’s Tullow Oil, India’s Essar, and two British companies, Sterling Energy
and Wilton Petroleum – all of which would be subject to sanctions for any
operational lapses. These licences could then be taken up by a new holding
company, a joint venture between the Malagasy States and the China International
Fund (CIF) to invest in local mining projects and business activities.
Hery Rajaonarimampianina, the Finance Minister, says he will release more
details before the end of March. According to Mamy Ratovomalala, Mines and
Hydrocarbons Minister, the plan is to evaluate all oil and mining exploration
projects and take away licences from companies breaking mining laws or not
pushing ahead quickly with production plans. Ratovomalala will likely reassign
many of the oil licences to CIF’s partner China Sonangol, which has been
operating in Angola and Guinea.
A joint-venture holding company between Madagascar and the CIF was launched at a
15 December Conseil des Ministres meeting. The meeting authorised the creation
of the Madagascar Development Corporation (MDC), which will manage the company’s
projects throughout the country, the same structure used in Guinea (AAC Vol 2 No
12). The MDC plans to work on agricultural, industrial, tourism and mining
projects. CIF will take 85% of the equity; the Antananarivo government will take
15%. Key to these deals with the Rajoelina regime is Mahmoud Thiam, Guinea’s
former Mines Minister and now director of CIF’s Guinean subsidiaries.
Leverage over licences
In what may be the first takeover by the CIF-led venture, Mines Ministry
officials called Madagascar Oil executives to a meeting in Antananarivo on 26
January. The officials explained the Ministry’s programme of audits and formally
requested to buy back the company’s licences on oil blocks 33104, 3105, 3106 and
3107.
The Office des mines nationales et des industries stratégiques in Antananarivo
had warned Madagascar Oil about the audit in a letter after a meeting in
mid-December. The audit of Madagascar Oil’s production sharing agreement would
take over month, say officials. Yet on 24 January, Minister Ratovomalala
referred to a new $1.2 bn. natural resources project that had started up without
giving precise details.
Madagascar Oil says it has invested over $200 million in the Tsimiroro oil
project. The government plans for an audit comes just as the company was listing
on London’s Alternative Investment Market. The Tsimiroro fields have at least
200 mn. barrels of oil, but some claim it could yield more than 3 billion
barrels. Given Madagascar Oil’s substantial investment in the project, the
government’s decision is likely to be strongly contested.
So far, the two sides are talking about the status of the production-sharing
contracts, but not the Bemolanga licence, part-owned by international giant
Total. The government may use the $7 mn. in back taxes owed by Total in 2010 as
a lever to push the company off its licence.
One company unlikely to be disturbed by the audits is Sino Union Energy
Investment Group (Sunpec), which holds rights to Blocks 2101, 2104, 3112 and
3113. Sunpec and its other Chinese partners struck oil on block 3113 in October.
In November, Sunpec named Yves-Roger Rajoelina, the President’s father and a
retired army colonel, as its special advisor.
Grasping for finance
Yet the CIF’s track record on raising finance in Angola and Guinea suggests it
will take months before the regime gets paid for any reassigned licences or gets
revenues from the joint venture projects. CIF – set up in Hong Kong in 2003 and
operating sometimes in Singapore – is a private company whose real financial
capacity is in doubt. But the reality is that Madagascar’s beleaguered Haute
Autorité de la Transition (HAT) regime, led by Andry Rajoelina, has been
struggling to find financing from any source.
Foreign-aid givers have blocked new credits since mid-2010 as they do not
recognise the HAT as legitimate and previous financing deals are expiring.
Budgetary discipline has enabled Antananarivo to keep paying salaries and basic
charges but new development projects have almost ground to a halt despite
assurances from Rajoelina.
The regime needs cash both to maintain its popular support and to strengthen
Rajoelina’s hand in negotiations overseen by SADC and the AU. Rajoelina is
pressuring his rivals, including former Presidents Marc Ravalomanana, Albert
Zafy and Didier Ratsiraka, into accepting the presidential elections that the
regime plans for mid-year.
The regime has had some success in persuading China to provide investment for
mining projects. In mid-2010, Hong Kong Wisco Guangxin Kam Wah Resources paid a
US$100 mn. signature bonus to a presidential fund for rights to the Soalala iron
ore deposit (AAC Vol 3 No 10).
Yet there are already problems with the consortium’s commitment to finance the
Soalala project. Kam Hing International Holdings, a Hong Kong-based garment
company in China and Madagascar, now says it was a stalking horse for other
interests. On 1 February, Kam Hing announced that it would sell 75% of Kam Hing
International Limited, which holds 20% of the Soalala mine, for $30 mn. Under
the deal, Kam Hing gets another payment of up to $70 mn. if the consortium finds
that Solala contains more than 200 mn. tonnes of ore.
The new owner of the 75% stake is an as-yet unnamed Chinese parastatal which
needs approval from the China’s National Development and Reform Commission to
make payments. Other investors in Soalala are state-owned Wuhan Iron and Steel
(Wisco) and the state-owned Guangdong Foreign Trade Group.
Prospects for CIF’s deals in Madagascar are uncertain given doubts about its
financial and management capacity as well as the economic stagnation and
political instability in the country. Another risk is the Rajoelina regime’s
lack of international recognition. A future Malagasy government may renegotiate
deals signed with the transitional regime. Yet for now Rajoelina is the
favourite to win any election after the political negotiations – despite his
earlier promise not to run.